Get a Quote

Key Person Insurance vs Relevant Life Insurance [What You Need To Know]

Key Person vs Relevant Life Insurance | IGotCover

Key Person vs Relevant Life Insurance

Both are life policies your limited company takes out and pays for, which is why directors so often confuse them, and the one difference that decides which you need is where the money lands. Key person insurance pays the business. Relevant life insurance pays your family.

Our verdict
For most limited company directors with dependants, relevant life insurance is usually the more broadly relevant of the two, and key person insurance is the one to add where the business itself would take a financial hit.
Relevant life insurance gives you death in service style cover funded by the company, with premiums usually treated as an allowable business expense and usually not a P11D benefit in kind for you, and a payout that usually reaches your family free of income tax through a trust. It also usually sits outside the lump sum and death benefit allowance, which matters if you have a sizeable pension. Key person insurance does a different job, compensating the company for lost profit or finding a replacement, and its tax treatment is less predictable because HMRC’s Anderson principles are not automatically satisfied. Neither is a substitute for the other, and plenty of directors hold both on the same life because their income is important to their family and they are important for their business.

The short answer

Key person insurance

A policy the company owns and pays for on someone the business could not easily replace. If that person dies, or is diagnosed with a covered critical illness where that option has been added, the insurer pays a lump sum to the business to cover lost profit, recruitment costs and disruption. Nobody’s family receives anything from it.

Relevant life insurance

A single life death in service style policy the company takes out on an employee or salaried director. It is written into a discretionary trust from outset, so the payout goes to that person’s family rather than into the business. It is defined at section 393B(4) of the Income Tax (Earnings and Pensions) Act 2003, with the detailed conditions in sections 481 and 482 of the Income Tax (Trading and Other Income) Act 2005.

The core difference

The beneficiary. Key person insurance is a business asset that turns a person’s death into cash for the company. Relevant life is an employee benefit that turns a person’s death into cash for their household. The company pays either way, and that shared funding is what makes people think they are alternatives when they are not.

There are structural differences worth knowing too. Relevant life insurance has to meet a set of statutory conditions: the term must end before age 75, the policy must not have or be capable of having a surrender value, the benefit must go to an individual or a charity, and tax avoidance must not be a main purpose. Key person insurance has no equivalent rulebook, because it is an ordinary business protection policy rather than a defined tax arrangement.

Side-by-side comparison

Ticked cells show which policy is usually the stronger option on that row. Rows marked with an equals sign are even, or depend on which loss you are covering.

FeatureKey person insuranceRelevant life insurance
Who receives the payoutThe business.Depends which loss you are coveringThe employee’s family, via a discretionary trust.
What it protectsCompany profit and continuity.Key person for profit, relevant life for familyThe household’s financial position.
Who owns and paysThe company.TieThe company.
Trust requiredNo.Stronger on simplicityYes, and it should be executed at outset.
Tax treatment of premiumsMay be allowable where the Anderson principles are met, not automatic, and often disallowed for significant shareholders.Usually an allowable business expense, subject to the wholly and exclusively test.More predictable
Benefit in kind for the individualNot applicable.Usually not treated as a P11D benefit.Usually no P11D charge
Tax treatment of the payoutUsually a taxable trading receipt where premiums were allowed, often a capital receipt where they were not.Usually reaches the family free of income tax, and normally outside the estate for inheritance tax.Usually tax free to the family
Pension allowance interactionNone.Usually does not count towards the lump sum and death benefit allowance of £1,073,100.Usually outside the allowance
Critical illness coverCan usually be added as an option.Critical illness availableNot permitted, though terminal illness benefit is usually included.
Maximum policy ageNo statutory limit, set by the insurer.No statutory age limitMust end before age 75.
EligibilityAny business insuring someone it depends on financially.Wider eligibilityEmployees and salaried directors only, not sole traders or equity partners.
How cover is sizedMultiple of earnings, or profit contribution over a recovery period.Neither, different basesMultiple of total remuneration, with the sum assured expected to be reasonable.
Portability if you change employerCover ends, it belongs to the company.Usually portable to a new employer or convertible to a personal policy.Usually portable
Complexity to arrangeLow to moderate, needs a defensible valuation of the person.TieLow to moderate, needs the right trust and a term ending before 75.
Who it suitsBusinesses where one or two people drive most of the profit.Depends on your circumstancesDirectors and employees with dependants or a mortgage.

Tax treatment depends on your circumstances and on legislation, both of which can change. HMRC allowability of premiums is not automatic and can be a matter for your local inspector. Trust wording should be reviewed with a suitably qualified adviser, and your accountant should confirm the corporation tax position in writing. Cover is subject to underwriting and acceptance.

Which is right for you?

Relevant life insurance points to you if
  • You have a mortgage, children or a partner whose standard of living depends on your income
  • You are paying for personal life cover out of money you have already been taxed on
  • You are the only person on the payroll, so a group death in service scheme is not open to you
  • You want a death benefit that usually sits outside the pension allowances
  • Your partner’s income alone would not keep the household running
  • You are a limited company director and want cover that is usually more tax efficient than a personal policy
Key person insurance points to you if
  • A small number of individuals bring in most of your revenue or hold the client relationships
  • Knowledge or technical capability sits in one person’s head rather than in documentation
  • Losing that person would mean months of reduced profit and a real recruitment cost
  • A lender, investor or major customer has asked what happens if a named person dies
  • You employ people whose wages would still need paying through a long disruption

Real-world scenarios

The examples below are illustrative only. They are not quotes, recommendations or predictions of cost or outcome. Cover, acceptance, premiums and tax treatment depend on your circumstances and the insurer’s terms.

Scenario A

The household that would struggle

Priya, 37, is a director of a consultancy with two other directors. She takes £12,570 in salary and around £58,000 in dividends, and has a £290,000 mortgage and two children at primary school.

Read the full scenario

The business would carry on without her, because her colleagues cover the same work. Her family would not.

A relevant life policy of £500,000 over 22 years, owned and paid for by the company and written into a discretionary trust, addresses the loss that actually bites here.

  • Salary£12,570
  • DividendsAround £58,000
  • Cover£500,000
✔ Likely better fit: relevant life insurance.
Get a relevant life quote →
Scenario B

The business that would struggle

A precision engineering firm employs a technical lead who designed and maintains the process behind roughly 40 per cent of its £900,000 gross profit. He is not a shareholder and has no dependants.

Read the full scenario

If he died, the company would face a long rebuild and would need to fund a senior replacement.

Key person insurance of around £700,000, owned by and payable to the company, covers the loss the business would feel.

  • Gross profit£900,000
  • Share behind one personAround 40%
  • CoverAround £700,000
✔ Likely better fit: key person insurance.
Get a key person quote →
Scenario C

The edge case, the sole director who is both

Tom, 44, owns 100 per cent of a consultancy, is the only person on the payroll, and has a wife and a £240,000 mortgage. He asks about key person cover.

Read the full scenario

Two problems surface. His shareholding means the premiums are unlikely to be allowable under the Anderson principles, which broadly expect the insured to be an employee without a significant stake.

More fundamentally, if he died there would be no continuing business to protect, so a payout to the company would sit in a shell that his estate then has to unwind. Relevant life sends the money where it is actually needed.

  • Shareholding100%
  • On the payrollJust him
  • Mortgage£240,000
✔ Likely better fit: relevant life insurance, with key person cover revisited if he later employs people the business depends on.
Get a relevant life quote →

The rule of thumb

So the company can keep trading through the loss of someone it relied onKey person insurance
So a household can keep paying its bills after losing the person who earned themRelevant life insurance

These two policies are answering different questions about the same death. Ask which of those two would be in trouble, and if the answer is both, that is not a contradiction, it is a reason to hold both.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between key person and relevant life insurance?
The beneficiary. Key person insurance pays a lump sum to the business when a named individual dies or becomes critically ill, so the company can absorb lost profit and recruitment costs. Relevant life insurance pays a lump sum to the individual’s family through a trust. Both are owned and funded by the company, which is why they are often confused, but the money goes to opposite places.
Can I have both policies on the same person?
Yes, and it is common where someone is both a revenue driver and a family provider. They cover separate losses, so holding both is not duplication. Expect insurers to look at the total cover across both policies and to want each amount justified, the key person figure against profit or earnings and the relevant life figure against total remuneration.
Which one is better for tax?
Relevant life insurance is usually the more predictable of the two. Premiums are typically an allowable business expense, usually not a P11D benefit for the individual, and the payout usually reaches the family free of income tax and outside the estate. Key person tax treatment depends on whether the Anderson principles are met, and where premiums are allowed the payout is usually a taxable trading receipt.
Can a sole trader take out relevant life insurance?
No. Relevant life requires an employer and an employee, and a sole trader is neither in relation to themselves. Equity partners are in the same position. If you trade through a limited company and are on its payroll, you are an employee of that company and can usually qualify. Sole traders normally use personal life cover written into trust instead.
Does relevant life insurance include critical illness cover?
No, and it cannot. Full critical illness cover is not permitted within the relevant life conditions, though terminal illness benefit is usually included as standard. Key person insurance can normally have critical illness added as an option at extra cost. If critical illness cover for yourself is the priority, personal cover or executive income protection may be the better conversation to have.
Who decides how much cover each policy needs?
You do, with an adviser, and both figures need evidencing. Key person cover is usually sized on a multiple of earnings or on the individual’s share of profit over a recovery period. Relevant life is usually a multiple of total remuneration including dividends, and the sum assured is expected to be reasonable in relation to the employee. Insurers will ask for accounts or remuneration records.

You might be interested in

Need one, the other, or both?

Speak to a business protection specialist at IGotCover. We will look at who would be in trouble if you were gone, the business or your household, then size each policy against something you can evidence and compare our panel of insurers. Free, and with no obligation.

Related posts