Key Person vs Death in Service
Key person insurance pays your company a lump sum if someone the business depends on dies, and death in service pays that person’s family a multiple of their salary. Both are funded by the business and both trigger on the same event, and the one difference that decides which you are looking at is whether the payout is meant to rescue your profit and loss account or your employee’s household.
The short answer
Key person insurance
A policy the business owns and pays for on an individual whose loss would hit its finances. If that person dies, or is diagnosed with a covered critical illness where that option has been added, the insurer pays a lump sum to the company.
The money is there to fund recruitment, absorb lost profit, reassure a lender and buy time while the business rebuilds. The family receives nothing from it.
Death in service
More properly called group life insurance, a scheme an employer sets up to pay a lump sum to an employee’s family if that employee dies while working for the business. It comes in two forms. A registered scheme is treated as a pension scheme for tax purposes, so benefits are tested against the lump sum and death benefit allowance. An excepted scheme sits outside the pension framework, but it can only pay lump sums for deaths before age 75, benefits must be calculated on the same basis for everyone insured, and the policy must have no cash value.
Most insurers will write a scheme for as few as two or three employees, which means the very smallest companies often cannot access one at all.
What the money is for. Death in service is compensation for a household. Key person insurance is working capital for a company. Death in service also covers everybody in the scheme on the same formula, while key person cover is deliberately selective and is sized to one named individual’s financial contribution.
Side-by-side comparison
Ticked cells show which policy is usually the stronger option on that row. Rows marked with an equals sign are even, or depend on which loss you are covering.
| Feature | Key person insurance | Death in service (group life) |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Protects the company’s profit and continuity.Depends which loss you are covering | Provides a benefit to an employee’s family. |
| Who receives the payout | The business.Key person for the business, death in service for the household | The employee’s family, via the scheme trustees. |
| Who is covered | Selected individuals only. | Usually all eligible employees in the scheme.Stronger on breadth |
| Minimum number of lives | One.Works for any size of business | Typically two or three employees, varies by insurer. |
| Who owns and pays | The company.Tie | The employer, under a trust. |
| What triggers a payout | Death, or covered critical illness where added.Critical illness option | Death in service, and terminal illness in some schemes. |
| Critical illness cover | Can usually be added at extra cost.Available as an add-on | Not usually part of a group life scheme. |
| Medical underwriting | Individual underwriting on the named person. | Often light or none up to a free cover limit for larger groups.Lighter for a team |
| How cover is sized | Multiple of earnings, or share of profit over a recovery period.Key person for precision, death in service for simplicity | A formula applied to everyone, usually a multiple of salary. |
| Tax treatment of premiums | May be allowable where HMRC’s Anderson principles are met, not automatic. | Usually an allowable business expense.More predictable |
| Benefit in kind | Not applicable, the company is the beneficiary. | Usually not treated as a P11D benefit.Usually no P11D charge |
| Tax treatment of the payout | Usually a taxable trading receipt where premiums were allowed. | Usually paid to the family through trust without income tax, subject to the allowance on registered schemes.Usually tax free to the family |
| Pension allowance interaction | None.Outside pension allowances | Registered schemes count towards the lump sum and death benefit allowance of £1,073,100 for 2026/27, excepted schemes usually do not. |
| Effect on recruitment and retention | None, staff are often unaware it exists. | A visible benefit you can advertise and talk about at interview.A benefit staff can see |
| Ongoing admin | Set up once, reviewed periodically.Lighter admin | Annual renewal, member data, trust documentation. |
| What happens without it | The business funds lost profit and recruitment from cash flow.Neither, both gaps hurt differently | Families are left with whatever personal cover the employee arranged. |
Tax treatment depends on your circumstances and on legislation, both of which can change. HMRC allowability of key person premiums is not automatic and can be a matter for your local inspector. Scheme trust arrangements should be reviewed with a suitably qualified adviser, and your accountant should confirm the corporation tax position in writing. Cover is subject to underwriting and acceptance.
Which is right for your business?
- One or a few individuals bring in most of your revenue or hold the client relationships personally
- Losing a specific person would mean months of reduced profit while you recruited and rebuilt
- Technical capability or supplier knowledge sits in one person’s head rather than in your systems
- A bank, investor or major customer has asked what happens to the business if a named person dies
- You have fewer than three people on the payroll, so a group scheme is not available to you anyway
- You employ enough people to meet an insurer’s minimum scheme size, usually two or three upwards
- You are competing for staff against larger employers who already offer it
- You want every employee covered on a consistent basis rather than picking individuals
- Some of your team would struggle to arrange personal life cover on reasonable terms
- You would rather manage one scheme at renewal than a policy per person
- You want a benefit your staff can see and value, which key person cover never is
Real-world scenarios
The examples below are illustrative only. They are not quotes, recommendations or predictions of cost or outcome. Cover, acceptance, premiums and tax treatment depend on your circumstances and the insurer’s terms.
The loss the business feels
A specialist manufacturer employs a technical director who designed and maintains the process behind roughly 45 per cent of its £1.1 million gross profit. He has no dependants and no shareholding.
Read the full scenario
If he died, the company would need to recruit at senior level, pay for a handover that cannot happen, and carry reduced output for well over a year.
Key person insurance of around £900,000, payable to the company, addresses the exposure that actually threatens the business.
- Gross profit£1.1 million
- Share behind one personAround 45%
- CoverAround £900,000
The loss the household feels
A digital agency has grown to 26 staff and keeps losing candidates to larger competitors at final interview. Most of the team are in their thirties with mortgages and young children, and very few have arranged personal life cover.
Read the full scenario
A group life scheme at four times salary covers everyone on the same basis, with light underwriting up to a free cover limit, and gives the business something concrete to put in front of candidates.
- Staff26
- CoverFour times salary
- UnderwritingLight, to a free cover limit
The edge case, the scheme that did not protect the business
A construction firm with 14 staff had death in service at four times salary and considered protection dealt with. Its managing director died.
Read the full scenario
His family received an illustrative £320,000, which was exactly what the scheme was designed to do. The company received nothing.
It then faced an estimated £280,000 shortfall in gross profit across the following year, a bank asking questions about its facility, and no cash to fund a replacement at that level. The scheme worked perfectly and covered none of the company’s exposure.
- Staff14
- Paid to the family£320,000
- Paid to the companyNothing
Get a key person quote →
The rule of thumb
Same death, two entirely separate problems, and a group scheme has never once paid a supplier invoice.
Frequently asked questions
Does death in service protect my business?
Can I have key person insurance and death in service at the same time?
What is the minimum number of employees for a death in service scheme?
Is key person insurance tax deductible?
How much death in service cover should we offer?
Which should we look at first?
You might be interested in
Covering the household, the business, or both?
Speak to a business protection specialist at IGotCover. We will look at what would break if a key person died, size key person cover against something you can evidence, and talk through whether a group scheme fits your headcount. Free, and with no obligation.
Important information: This article is general information and not advice. It does not take account of your personal or business circumstances and is not a recommendation to take out any particular policy. Cover, acceptance, premiums and tax treatment are never guaranteed and depend on your circumstances. Tax treatment depends on individual circumstances and can change, HMRC allowability of premiums is not automatic and can be a matter for the local inspector, and your accountant should confirm the position. Scheme and trust arrangements should be reviewed with a suitably qualified adviser. For advice tailored to your business, speak to an IGotCover adviser. IGotCover is the business protection brand of Caspian Assured Ltd, authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA reference 788964).