Relevant Life Insurance vs Private Health Insurance
Relevant life insurance pays a lump sum to an employee’s family if that employee dies, and private health insurance pays for their treatment while they are alive. Your company can fund either, and the difference that changes the decision for anyone signing off a benefits budget is that one of them creates a tax charge on every person you cover and the other usually does not.
The short answer
Relevant life insurance
A single life death in service style policy the company takes out on an employee or salaried director, written into a discretionary trust so the benefit reaches that person’s family rather than the business. It is defined at section 393B(4) of the Income Tax (Earnings and Pensions) Act 2003 and must satisfy specific conditions: the term ends before age 75, the policy has no surrender value, the benefit goes to an individual or a charity, and critical illness cover cannot be included, though terminal illness benefit usually can.
Private health insurance
Also called private medical insurance, it pays for private diagnosis and treatment so someone is seen faster and has a say in where and when. It pays providers for eligible treatment rather than paying cash to the individual, and it typically excludes chronic conditions and pre-existing conditions. It buys speed and choice, not financial replacement.
What each one buys you as an employer. Health insurance is an operational benefit, because getting a key person diagnosed and treated in six weeks rather than six months has a direct effect on output. Relevant life is a duty of care benefit, because it does nothing for productivity and everything for a household that has just lost its earner. Most businesses eventually want both, and the sequencing usually comes down to budget and headcount.
What each costs you per £1,000 of premium
The same £1,000 of annual premium, followed through the tax system to see what it actually costs the company and the employee.
| Cost line, per £1,000 of annual premium | Relevant life insurance | Private health insurance |
|---|---|---|
| Premium paid by the company | £1,000 | £1,000 |
| Employer Class 1A National Insurance | £0 | £150 |
| Total company outlay before relief | £1,000 | £1,150 |
| Corporation tax relief at 25 per cent | £250 | £288 |
| Net cost to the company | £750 | £862 |
| Income tax paid by a basic rate employee | £0 | £200 |
| Income tax paid by a higher rate employee | £0 | £400 |
| Annual P11D or payrolling entry required | No | Yes, for every covered person |
Illustrative only, assuming corporation tax relief at the 25 per cent main rate and Class 1A National Insurance at 15 per cent for 2026/27. Your own rates, allowability and employee tax bands will differ.
Side-by-side comparison
Ticked cells show which is usually the stronger option on that row. Rows marked with an equals sign are even, or depend on what you are trying to solve.
| Feature | Relevant life insurance | Private health insurance |
|---|---|---|
| What the business is buying | A death benefit for an employee’s family.Depends on what you are trying to solve | Faster diagnosis and treatment for an employee. |
| Effect on productivity | None. | Direct, where it shortens time away from work.Keeps people working |
| Benefit in kind for the employee | Usually not a P11D benefit.No personal tax charge | Yes, taxed on the cash equivalent at their marginal rate. |
| Employer National Insurance | None.No Class 1A | Class 1A at 15 per cent for 2026/27. |
| Premium tax treatment for the company | Usually an allowable business expense.Tie | Usually an allowable business expense. |
| Payroll and reporting burden | Set up once, then almost nothing.Lighter admin | Annual reporting or payrolling for every covered person. |
| How it scales across a team | One policy per person, each individually underwritten. | Can be arranged individually or as a group scheme, with cost per head usually falling at scale.Stronger once you have a team |
| Minimum number of lives | One, which suits sole director companies.Tie | Available individually or as a scheme, with scheme minimums varying. |
| Visible value to staff | Rarely noticed until a claim. | Used, appreciated and mentioned at interview.A benefit staff can see |
| Premium stability | Usually fixed at outset for the term.More predictable | Reviewed annually and typically rises with age and claims. |
| Pension allowance interaction | Usually sits outside the lump sum and death benefit allowance of £1,073,100 for 2026/27.Usually outside the allowance | None. |
| Chronic and pre-existing conditions | Handled at underwriting, then the cover is settled.Settled at the start | Usually excluded, which surprises people at the point of claim. |
| Maximum age | Term must end before age 75. | Can usually continue into later life, subject to the insurer.No hard age limit |
| Eligibility | Employees and salaried directors only, not sole traders or equity partners. | Anyone, personally or through a company.Wider eligibility |
| What happens if you drop it | The family loses a benefit they were never told about.Neither, they fail differently | The team notices immediately. |
Tax treatment depends on individual circumstances and can change. HMRC allowability of premiums is not automatic and can be a matter for the local inspector, and your accountant should confirm the position in writing. Cover is subject to underwriting and acceptance.
Which should your business fund?
- You have a small team of people on the payroll, so a group death in service scheme is not available to you
- You want to fund a benefit without creating a tax charge for the people receiving it
- Some of your team, or you, have substantial pension savings and want death benefits that usually sit outside the pension allowances
- Your directors are paying for personal life cover out of income they have already been taxed on
- A long wait for a scan or procedure would take a revenue critical person out of action for months
- You are losing candidates at final interview to larger employers who offer it as standard
- Your people are in physically demanding roles where musculoskeletal issues are common
- You want a benefit the team actively uses and talks about rather than one they forget exists
IGotCover advises on business protection. Private medical insurance is a general insurance product and may need to be arranged through a specialist.
Real-world scenarios
The examples below are illustrative only. They are not quotes, recommendations or predictions of cost or outcome. Cover, acceptance, premiums and tax treatment depend on your circumstances and the insurer’s terms.
The small company with no benefits budget history
An engineering consultancy with four staff wants to offer something meaningful for the first time on a budget of around £4,000 a year. Its team is young, mostly with mortgages and young children, and none of them have life cover beyond what came with an old workplace pension.
Read the full scenario
Relevant life policies for all four, funded by the company, use the budget without creating a personal tax charge for anyone and without adding a reporting line to the payroll.
- StaffFour
- BudgetAround £4,000 a year
- Tax charge for staffNone
The business that loses output to waiting times
A specialist installation firm has eight engineers whose work is physical, with a recurring pattern of shoulder and back problems. Each episode has historically meant months on light duties while waiting for assessment.
Read the full scenario
Private health insurance across the team brings diagnosis and treatment forward considerably, and the directors calculate that reducing the average absence materially outweighs the premiums and the Class 1A charge.
- EngineersEight
- WorkPhysical
- Recurring issueShoulders and backs
The edge case, the benefit nobody costed properly
A marketing agency with 12 staff had offered company paid health insurance for three years at an average of £1,300 per person. The finance director reviewed it and found the annual Class 1A charge came to roughly £2,340 on top of £15,600 in premiums.
Read the full scenario
Every employee was also carrying income tax on the benefit in their tax code, which several had never understood. Usage across the three years had been concentrated in two people.
The agency kept the health cover for senior staff, added relevant life for everybody, and ended up with broader coverage for a similar total outlay.
- Staff12
- Premiums£15,600
- Class 1A on topAround £2,340
Get a relevant life quote →
The rule of thumb
One shows up in your productivity and on your P11D, the other shows up only once, for a family who will never see the invoice.
Frequently asked questions
Is company paid private health insurance a taxable benefit for employees?
Does relevant life insurance create a benefit in kind for our staff?
Which benefit gives us more for the same budget?
Can we offer relevant life insurance to employees as well as directors?
Do we have to offer the same benefit to everyone?
Does health insurance help if someone cannot work at all?
You might be interested in
Choosing what the business should fund?
Speak to a business protection specialist at IGotCover. We will look at relevant life for your team, set up the trusts, and if long absences are the real concern, look at executive income protection too. Free, and with no obligation.
Important information: This article is general information and not advice. It does not take account of your business circumstances and is not a recommendation to take out any particular policy. Cover, acceptance, premiums and tax treatment are never guaranteed and depend on your circumstances. Tax treatment depends on individual circumstances and can change, HMRC allowability of premiums is not automatic and can be a matter for the local inspector, and your accountant should confirm the position. Trust wording should be reviewed with a suitably qualified adviser. IGotCover advises on business protection. Private medical insurance is a general insurance product and may need to be arranged through a specialist. For advice on protecting your business, speak to an IGotCover adviser. IGotCover is the business protection brand of Caspian Assured Ltd, which is directly authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority under firm reference number 788964.