The Best Insurance for Growth Stage Companies
Growth can mean borrowing, new shareholders, specialist hires and a payroll, usually in that order and usually faster than the paperwork keeps up. The one difference that decides which business protection policies come first is where you’re most at risk.
The short answer
Repays an outstanding debt if the person behind it dies or, where the option is added, is diagnosed with a critical illness. That covers commercial mortgages, bank loans, asset finance, overdrafts, directors’ loan accounts and facilities supported by a personal guarantee.
Provides the money for surviving owners to buy a deceased or critically ill shareholder’s stake, so ownership stays with the people running the business. It sits alongside a legal agreement, usually a cross option agreement, drafted by a solicitor.
Pays a lump sum to the company if a named individual dies or, where added, becomes critically ill, so the business can absorb lost profit, fund recruitment and keep trading while it rebuilds.
A death in service style policy the company takes out on an employee or salaried director, written into a discretionary trust so the payout goes to their family rather than the business.
Who or what each one rescues. Business loan protection rescues the balance sheet and any personal guarantors. Shareholder protection rescues the ownership structure. Key person insurance rescues trading profit. Relevant life rescues a household. Growth stage companies tend to acquire all four exposures within a short space of time, which is why this is rarely a question of picking one.
The order to put it in place
Key person insurance is usually the starting point. After that, three things tend to set the order.
- What is paying for the growthWhat comes next depends on what’s paying for the growth. If it’s an investment, key person cover matters even more, because investors are backing the people as much as the plan, and some will ask for it as a condition of funding. If it’s borrowing, look at business loan protection alongside it, especially where a director has signed a personal guarantee. A personal guarantee is the one exposure that can reach beyond the company and into someone’s home.
- Whatever changed most recentlyAfter that, the order usually follows whatever has changed most recently. New shareholders mean it’s time to look at shareholder protection and a cross option agreement. A growing payroll is a reason to look at relevant life. And every new specialist hire is a reason to revisit your key person cover.
- A review every year while you scaleGrowth businesses rarely get caught out by having no cover at all. More often, the cover they have hasn’t kept up. A shareholder protection policy set when the business was worth £600,000 does roughly half the job once it’s worth £1.2 million. Key person cover sized when a founder brought in £200,000 of profit won’t go far once they’re bringing in twice that. Growing companies tend to outgrow their cover faster than they review it, so an annual review usually makes more sense than the two-yearly cycle that suits a more stable business.
What changes when you scale, and what it exposes
| What growth brings | What it exposes you to | Which cover responds |
|---|---|---|
| Debt taken on to fund expansion | The facility survives the person who signed for it. | Business loan protection |
| Personal guarantees given by founders | A director’s home and savings, not just the company. | Business loan protection |
| Directors’ loan accounts funding working capital | A balance that becomes repayable or contested on death. | Business loan protection |
| New investors or equity given to key hires | Shares passing to a family member who has no role in the business. | Shareholder protection plus a cross option agreement |
| A rising valuation | Cover that no longer matches what the shares are worth. | Shareholder protection reviewed annually |
| Specialist hires who are not yet duplicated | Concentrated knowledge and client relationships in one person. | Key person insurance |
| A small number of large contracts | Revenue that walks out with the person who holds the relationship. | Key person insurance |
| Cash reinvested rather than reserved | A thin buffer at precisely the point exposure is highest. | All four, since none of them rely on your own cash |
| Competing for talent against larger employers | Losing hires you need to sustain the growth. | Relevant life insurance |
| Lender, investor or acquirer due diligence | Questions about continuity you cannot answer. | Key person insuranceShareholder protection |
The pattern worth noticing is that growth raises every one of these exposures at the same time as it consumes the cash that would otherwise absorb them. A stable business with reserves can self insure a surprising amount. A business ploughing everything back into growth generally cannot.
Side-by-side comparison
Ticked cells show which cover is usually the stronger option on that row. Rows marked with an equals sign are even, or depend on the exposure.
| Feature | Business loan protection | Shareholder protection | Key person insurance | Relevant life insurance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| What it protects | A specific debt.Depends on the exposure | Ownership and control. | Trading profit. | An employee’s family. |
| Who receives the money | The business, or the lender directly.Different destinations | The surviving shareholders, who pay the estate. | The business. | The employee’s family, via trust. |
| Who owns and pays | Usually the company.Tie | Usually each shareholder, often under trust. | The company. | The company. |
| Legal agreement needed | No, the loan agreement exists.No new agreement | Yes, a cross option agreement from a solicitor. | No. | No, but a trust deed is required. |
| How cover is sized | Matched to the outstanding balance.Most precise | Matched to each shareholder’s stake, needs a valuation. | Multiple of earnings or share of profit over a recovery period. | Multiple of total remuneration. |
| How often to review when scaling | On any new borrowing or refinancing. | Annually, as valuation moves.Needs the closest watch | Annually, as profit and roles change. | On pay rises and new hires. |
| Premium tax treatment | Allowability follows the purpose of the loan, not automatic. | Usually not allowable for the company. | May be allowable where the Anderson principles are met. | Usually an allowable business expense.Most predictable |
| Payout tax treatment | Usually a taxable trading receipt where premiums were allowed. | Usually free of income tax when written under trust.Usually tax free | Usually a taxable trading receipt where premiums were allowed. | Usually free of income tax, normally outside the estate.Usually tax free |
| Benefit in kind | Not applicable. | Not applicable. | Not applicable. | Usually not a P11D benefit.Usually no P11D charge |
| Protects personal assets | Yes, where a guarantee exists.Protects guarantors | Indirectly, by giving the estate a buyer. | No. | No, it protects the household. |
| Helps with recruitment | No. | No. | No. | Yes, it is a visible benefit.A benefit staff can see |
| Matters in due diligence | Yes, lenders often ask. | Yes, investors and acquirers ask.Asked about most | Yes, particularly where revenue is concentrated.Asked about most | Rarely. |
| Needed if you are a sole owner with no staff | Yes, if there is borrowing.Relevant to a sole owner with debt | No. | Sometimes, if others depend on the business. | Yes, if you have dependants. |
Tax treatment depends on your circumstances and on legislation, both of which can change. HMRC allowability of premiums is not automatic and can be a matter for your local inspector. IGotCover advises on protection insurance and does not draft legal agreements, so cross option and shareholder agreements must be prepared by a solicitor, and your accountant should confirm the tax position in writing. Cover is subject to underwriting and acceptance.
Which is right for your business?
- You have hired specialists whose roles nobody else in the business can currently cover
- A small number of clients or contracts sit with one or two named individuals
- Losing a specific person would mean months of reduced profit while you recruited
- A lender, investor or major customer has asked what happens if a named person dies
- Your growth depends on capability that lives in someone’s head rather than your systems
- You are approaching a funding round or a sale where continuity will be examined
- You have taken on a growth facility, asset finance or a commercial mortgage in the last two years
- You or a co-director has signed a personal guarantee supporting any of it
- Founders have lent money into the business and the directors’ loan accounts are substantial
- A lender has made cover a condition of the facility, which is increasingly common
- You are planning to borrow and want the cover arranged before the funds draw down
- You would rather a debt was cleared than serviced from reduced trading profit
- You have brought in an investor, a co-founder or a key hire on equity
- Your valuation has moved materially since the last time anyone looked at the paperwork
- Nobody has written down what happens to shares when a shareholder dies
- Your articles of association are the standard model articles and have never been reviewed
- The other shareholders could not fund a share purchase from personal savings
- You have an old agreement and nobody has checked whether it is a cross option or a binding buy and sell
- You are competing for hires against larger employers who offer death in service
- You have fewer than three people on the payroll, so a group scheme is not available
- Your founders take a small salary and have most of their net worth locked in the business
- Directors are paying for personal life cover from income they have already been taxed on
- Some of your team have pension savings large enough that the allowances matter
- You want a benefit that costs the company the premium and nothing else
Real-world scenarios
The examples below are illustrative only. They are not quotes, recommendations or predictions of cost or outcome. Cover, acceptance, premiums and tax treatment depend on your circumstances and the insurer’s terms.
The facility that came with a signature
A logistics business takes a £750,000 growth facility to fund vehicles and a new depot, supported by personal guarantees from both founding directors. Six months later one of them dies.
Read the full scenario
The facility does not pause, and the guarantee means his estate, and in practice his family home, is within reach of the lender.
Business loan protection matched to the balance and the remaining term would have cleared the debt and released the guarantee.
- Facility£750,000
- Personal guaranteesBoth founders
- DeathSix months in
Get a business loan protection quote →
The equity nobody documented
A software company brings in a commercial director on a 15 per cent stake to drive the next stage of growth. There is no shareholders’ agreement, no cross option agreement and no funding in place.
Read the full scenario
Two years later the business is valued at around £2.4 million and her stake is worth roughly £360,000.
If she died, that stake would pass into her estate with nothing obliging anyone to sell and nothing available to buy it with, leaving the founders sharing decisions with someone they have never met.
- Stake15%
- ValuationAround £2.4 million
- Stake worthAround £360,000
Get a shareholder protection quote →
The switch case, where the key person moved
A manufacturing business arranged £250,000 of key person cover on its founder three years ago, when he personally handled every customer relationship.
Read the full scenario
Since then he has stepped back into a strategic role and a new commercial director has taken over the accounts driving around 55 per cent of a now much larger gross profit.
The cover is still sitting on the founder at a figure set for a smaller company. The exposure has moved to a different person and grown considerably, and nobody has revisited the file.
- Cover in place£250,000
- SetThree years ago
- Profit now with someone elseAround 55%
Get a key person quote →
The rule of thumb
Growth stage businesses do not fail from one shock, they fail because the shock arrives while the cash is already committed elsewhere.
Each of these four policies exists so that a death or serious illness does not become a funding problem:
Check them the same year you check your facilities, because both grow at the same speed.
Frequently asked questions
What insurance should a growing company get first?
Do we need shareholder protection if we have just taken on an investor?
How often should a growing business review its cover?
Does a lender require key person insurance?
Can a startup with three employees get death in service?
Is business protection worth it when cash is tight?
You might be interested in
Which of the four comes first for you?
Speak to a business protection specialist at IGotCover. We will look at what is funding your growth, who carries the risk now, and what has changed since your cover was last set, then size each policy and compare our panel of insurers. Free, and with no obligation.
Important information: This article is general information and not advice. It does not take account of your business circumstances and is not a recommendation to take out any particular policy or adopt any particular legal structure. IGotCover advises on business protection insurance and does not provide legal or tax advice. Cross option and shareholder agreements must be drafted by a solicitor. Cover, acceptance, premiums and tax treatment are never guaranteed and depend on your circumstances. Tax treatment depends on individual circumstances and can change, HMRC allowability of premiums is not automatic and can be a matter for the local inspector, and your accountant should confirm the position. For advice tailored to your business, speak to an IGotCover adviser. IGotCover is the business protection brand of Caspian Assured Ltd, which is directly authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority under firm reference number 788964.